Oakland Raiders Positional Breakdown and Draft Possibilites: The Offense
Quarterbacks:
Currently under contract: JaMarcus Russell, Bruce Gradkowski, Charlie Frye, JP Losman
Analysis: For now, forget anything you may have heard about Al Davis using the uncapped year to rid himself of JaMarcus Russell. Davis is committed to giving Russell at least one more year and the recent signing of Hue Jackson as offensive co-ordinator only re-inforces that belief. There's some speculation that Davis may cut Russell at the end of training camp if he shows up fat and out of shape again and stinks up the practices.
Gradkowski is an RFA and it's hard to imagine the Raiders not taking advantage of that fact to keep him around, given how effective he was when Cable finally got fed up and benched Russell.
Charlie Frye started as 3rd stringer and ended up starting due to the ineptness of Russell and injuries to Gradkowski. He did well enough, I suppose, though his play seemed to indicate he'll never be anything other than a backup in the league. He is a UFA, but will be an RFA if the uncapped year happens.
JP Losman was signed as emergency third stringer and threw 1 incomplete pass against Denver.
It's not a hard thing to imagine the Raiders standing pat on quarterbacks. Russell isn't going anywhere (for now) and with Gradkowski and Frye having a year in the system and played anywhere from adequately to good, it should be a simple matter to put a RFA tender on both of them. Diffcult to imagine other teams beating a path to their door in any case. Losman may be kept around to provide camp competition for Frye, with the winner getting the 3rd string position.
Will the Raiders draft a QB? I don't see it, though Davis may take a flyer on someone like Fordham's John Skelton or Troy's Levi Brown in the 7th round if Losman isn't kept for camp.
Running back
Currently under contract: Darren McFadden, Justin Fargas, Michael Bush
Analysis: One of the main disappointments of the Raiders 2009 season was the inability to make proper use of their talented triumverate of runners. Each has complimentary strengths and weaknesses. Each of these guys have concerns: McFadden doesn't fight through tackles enough, Bush has problems with conditioning and Fargas is injury prone. However, given that all are under contract through the 2011 season, it's hard to imagine any of them going anywhere. Instead the Raiders will hope Hue Jackson can use them more effectively. There's an outside chance Michael Bush may be dangled as trade bait on draft day.
Will the Raiders draft a RB? Extremely unlikely, unless Al falls in love with someone at the Combine. Then you may see Bush or Fargas shopped.
Fullback:
Currently under contract: Oren O'Neal, Luke Lawton, Marcel Reese, Gary Russell
Analysis: The organization loves Oren O'Neal, but he has sustained two major, season-ending injuries in as many years. Luke Lawton was ineffective, suspended for violating the league substance abuse policy and is a free agent in any case. He's almost certainly gone. Reese was promoted from the practice squad after Lawton's suspension and Gary Russell is a converted running back who is an average blocker, but talented at catching passes out of the backfield. Part of the reason the running game fell short of expectations was the fact that the lead blocking was at times absolutely woeful.
Oren O'Neal has potential, but who knows if he can ever stay healthy. Marcel Reese is uninspiring and Gary Russell is not a natural fullback. The position is a need.
Will the Raiders draft a fullback? It's virtually certain a new one will be picked up. Rashawn Jackson, John Conner and Cory Jackson are all possibilities in rounds 5-7. At the least, I predict someone signed as a UDFA.
Offensive tackle:
Currently under contract: Mario Henderson, Khalif Barnes, Cornell Green, Langston Walker, Erik Pears
Analysis: Up and down year for this group. Mario Henderson started off the year incredibly strong, just as he had finished 2008. Unfortunately, he faded as the year went on and by the end was struggling. I tend to blame a lot of this on the injury to Robert Gallery as Henderson suddenly wasn't feeling as comfortable that the blocking assignment to his right was taken care of. Still, he has to learn to manage on his own.
Cornell Green is an unmitigated disaster at right tackle and his contract is expiring. He is a good run blocker, but is a liability in pass protection and is a false start machine. To the delight of Raider Nation, his time in Oakland is probably coming to a close.
Khalif Barnes was signed to great fanfare to compete with Henderson for the left tackle spot. Instead, he got injured and was terrible when plugged in at right tackle when Cornell Green was hurt. He's a UFA and probably not returning.
Erik Pears was signed as depth and didn't do much to inspire. Again, he was unimpressive when given a shot at right tackle, but was surprisingly competent as guard and as an extra tight end in "jumbo" sets. He may be kept around as depth.
Langston Walker was signed during the season as depth tackle. Can't remember if he even played the position, but did step in at guard and was shockingly good. Again, he may be kept around as depth tackle/guard.
Will the Raiders draft a tackle? It's as close to a lock as you can get. Right tackle is maybe the single biggest need on the team. They need a reliable pass protector and mauling run blocker at that position. Anthony Davis and Trent Williams are the likeliest possibilities. In addition, Bruce Campbell or Bryan Bulaga may be selected with the thought of moving Henderson to the right side.
Guard:
Currently under contract: Robert Gallery, Cooper Carlisle, Chris Morris
Analysis: The single best thing Tom Cable has done for the Raiders organization was to rescue Robert Gallery's career. A bust at left tackle and mediocre right tackle, the shift to guard has converted Gallery into a dominant mauler and made left guard the one position on the offensive line the Raiders have zero concerns at. Problem: That's when he's healthy. Gallery underwent a siege of injuries this year. If he can stay healthy an entire season, I firmly believe he'll receive serious Pro Bowl consideration. He's that good at guard.
Cooper Carlisle was once one of the game's best guards. Time has taken its toll, however and he showed a marked and disturbing decline in 2009. He'll need replacing soon, though he's under contract for several more years. Gotta love Davis and his contracts.
Chris Morris is a versatile backup who can play both center and guard. He struggled with full time starting duties, however and seemed overwhelmed at times. He's an RFA and a Cable favorite, so you'll probably see him retained.
As mentioned above, both Langston Walker and Erik Pears were serviceable when plugged into guard at various times during the season.
Will the Raiders draft a guard? Odds are very good, considering the depth of this year's guard class, which is one of the best in years. Cable was reportedly enamored of Mike Iupati (no surprise there), though to get him the Raiders will either have to reach or trade back into the mid-first or up again into the late-first to get him. As we all know, though, this is one organization that says "reaches be damned, this is who we want." Iupati's a natural left guard and Robert Gallery isn't going anywhere, but I have a hunch Cable thinks he could teach Iupati to play right guard or even right tackle.
Cable and Davis also like versatile linemen who can play multiple positions. It's not out of the realm of possibility they might snatch up a guy like Maurkice Pouncey in round 2. In addition, keep your eyes on guys like Mike Johnson, Marshall Newhouse, Brandon Carter or Jon Asamoah in rounds 3 or 4. (Like I said, this is a deep guard class)
Center:
Currently under contract: Samson Satele
Analysis: Satele was brought in from the Dolphins in a trade that saw former Raiders center Jake Grove shipped off to Miami. Sadly, Satele struggled to learn the nuances of the center position in the zone-blocking system. The center is perhaps the most important position in the ZBS, as he is required to diagnose the defense at the line and call out any blocking corrections. Satele was so bad at this, that Chris Morris actually won the starting job as center out of camp.
Happily, Satele improved by leaps and bounds as the season went on and was a perfectly adequate starter by the end. However, "adequate" doesn't really cut it in the NFL and it's likely the Raiders will be on the lookout for someone to push Satele and maybe even win the starting job.
Will the Raiders draft a center? Odds are good that at the least, someone will be signed as a UDFA, though a center will probably be drafted. As I said above, Maurkice Pouncey's versatility and athleticism (potentially might run a 5.1 at almost 320 pounds) could have him squarely on Oakland's radar in round 2. J.D. Walton from Baylor and Eric Olsen out of Notre Dame could be snapped up with one of Oakland's round 3 picks. Finally, Kenny Alfred, Erik Cook, Jacob Hickman and Chris Fisher are all possibilties at the tail end of the draft or as UDFAs. (Have I mentioned this is a great year for teams with offensive line problems?)
Wide Receivers:
Currently under contract: Darrius Heyward-Bey, Chaz Schilens, Louis Murphy, Javon Walker, Todd Watkins, Johnnie Lee Higgins
Analysis: This is a group with a bright future, though you wouldn't much know it from their performance last year. They and JaMarcus Russell were caught in a sort of mutual cycle of destruction as the struggles of each fed off each other.
Darrius Heyward-Bey is almost too much of a cipher to even evaluate. To call him massively disappointing is perhaps the understatement of the year. Like so many Davis draft picks, he's a raw project full of potential the organization seems forever unable to develop. Can't call him a bust yet, no matter how bad he seemed. We'll know more after this season. In any event, he's not going anywhere anytime soon.
Chaz Schilens is the Raiders' no. 1 receiver. That may sound like a bad thing since he was a 7th round pick out of a small school. But if you think that, you haven't seen Schilens play. He's a great route runner who catches just about everything thrown his way. He missed much of last year with a nagging foot injury, but if he can stay healthy in 2010, he's poised for a breakout season.
Louis Murphy impressed most observers this season, including me. As the season went on and his confidence improved, he began to assume the position of the Raiders #2 receiver. Look for him to continue the strong upward trend.
Javon Walker. What a sad disappointment. Was inactive for almost every game this year and I have to think Davis will honor his request for a release sometime over the summer.
Johnnie Lee Higgins was struck with a crisis of confidence after week 1 when Russell hung him out to dry on a crossing route and Eric Weddle nearly killed him with a hellacious hit. He was hesitant and tenative from then on and his punt returning ability also suffered. He needs to pick it up. There's an outside chance he'll be a camp casualty if he doesn't improve, though I suspect he'll be around for 2010.
Todd Watkins is your classic 4th or 5th receiver--pretty uninspiring, but could be worse. Guys like him come and go. He could be gone, he could be back.
Will the Raiders draft a receiver? Not in the first 3 rounds and probably not in the 4th either. A lot depends on if guys like Javon Walker, JLH and Watkins are cut. If you're looking for possible names in late rounds: Riley Cooper, Marcus Easley, Taylor Price and Antonio Brown are the ones I'd consider most likely
Tight ends:
Currently under contract: Zach Miller, Brandon Myers, Tony Stewart
Analysis: Zach Miller is the best tight end you've probably never heard of. An outstanding blocker, he truly excels in the passing game. He's one of two receivers (the other is Schilens) that JaMarcus Russell ever developed any chemistry with and has acted as his security blanket for 3 seasons now.
The organization likes Brandon Myers so much that they actually moved up last year to make sure they got him. Drafted primarily as a blocker, he showed a surprising talent for catching during camp.
Tony Stewart is a decent enough "jack of all trades, master of none" option.
Will the Raiders draft a tight end? Doubtful, since Miller is the clear #1 and I don't see who they'd get that would be any better than Myers or Stewart.
Coming soon: Part 2....the defense!
If it's deemed spam, it gets deleted.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Nice write up.
The only thing I tend to disagree with (slightly) is the WR position. I could see them taking one in round 2. I agree that Davis is committed to Russell and I could see Davis using the whole damn draft on offense just to help Russell succeed.
Very nice write up.
McShay, Todd McShay you hear me boy? It's me TJ and I'm coming for your damn job boy! Oh be scared, be very scared McShay.
How fast are the players you want?
The Raiders are a team that needs upgrade in almost every position (I’d say your secondary is your strength as a team, which means that you guys will definitely have an offensive focused draft). I just find it hard to believe the Raiders have struck out on so many consecutive 1st round picks, apart from Nnamdi.
What do you think the main issue is?
As I said in S&BP
I’m hoping for all beef with the first 4 picks (hold the JaMarcus). Got to improve the thin offensive and defensive lines. Maybe a OT first to protect Al Davis’ horrible investment JaGantus, and the very tackler friendly DMac.
Woohoo, I get to look forward to another 7-6 season ("at best") in 2010! There's nothing like going to Idaho for a bowl game.
What would it take for the Raiders to trade out of #8?
First let me say this is an excellent review of the players that will be in the draft. I cannot really comment too much on the Raiders roster as a Viking fan.
I would like my Vikings to trade up with Oakland to draft Bradford or Clausen if either is available.
I am thinking that the Vikings could offer this ..
2010 #1 pick 30 (620 points)
2010 #2 pick 62 (284 points)
2010 #3 pick 93 (128 points)
2011 #2 pick 30 (284 points)
Bryant McKinnie (worth at least a 2nd which using pick #39 as a guide is 510 points)
total points is 1826
for the Raiders …
2010 #1 pick 8 (1400 points)
2010 #2 pick 69 (245 points)
2010 #4 pick 103 (88 points)
2010 #5 pick 134 (39 points)
2011 #6 pick 166 (25 points)
total points is 1797
Basically the Vikings give their first this year, second next year, swap their second for the Raiders first third, swap their third for the Raiders first fourth, and receive the Raiders first fifth and maybe the Raiders sixth next year.
The Raiders get the Vikings first this year, second next year, and do the swaps.
The Raiders will still have these picks in the draft 30,39,62,85,93,149,&199 and a 2nd round pick next year which is one less than they had before.
But they will not have to pay the #8 money and they get an extra second next year which could be better than the #30 which is what they go by when doing these trades. The Raiders have been picking in the top 10 and paying top 10 money for the last six years except for once when they traded for Moss and the Vikings ended up with the #7 pick which they wasted on Troy Williamson.
McKinnie is a Pro Bowl level LT who has about 3 years left on his contract at 4 mil per year which is a lot less than top LTs make. Salary wise this is a bargain for the Raiders and it fills a need.
So why would the Vikings give up on McKinnie? Well you have to give something to get something. The Vikings will struggle at the LT spot perhaps. But they have to get a QB.
Another package that may suit the Raiders taste is the Vikings 2010 & 2011 first round picks plus McKinnie (1750 points) for the Raiders 2010 1st #8, 3rd #69, 5th #134, & 2011 5th (1723 points).
But maybe the Raiders do not want McKinnie? Maybe they will take Ray Edwards instead for the same deals?
Call me crazy but the Vikings need to get a top QB and if they are going to continue to make the playoffs then they will be picking too low normally. Right now the Vikings can add nothing and just resign their RFAs and have the same roster as last year. Now is the time for them to make a move on the QB of the future hopefully.
interesting
This might have had a different answer before the Pro Bowl. Oakland has a bad history with linemen wandering away from the team before a game. McKenzie gave up 9 sacks this year, which actually puts him in the bottom half or maybe quarter of left tackles. There are rumors that Minnesota is not happy with him. But his salary is a good deal.
The Raiders used to be known more for toughness than speed. They need to reclaim that. All their early picks should be along the line. I could see two offensive linemen in the first three rounds.
McKinnie & the Pro Bowl
I agree that what McKinnie did was an embarassment but more to himself than the Vikings. He was banged up but tried to show up but then decided he did not want to play. At this point is where he failed to communicate to EVERYBODY that he could not go IMHO.
Some say why did he wait until he got there to realize he could not go? I think it was because it was his first time making the Pro Bowl (he should have made it at least once before but sometimes the voting is a popularity contest) and he really wanted to go.
As for him being out at clubs at night, well first he is a “music producer” and he was asked to “host” a party at one club. I think he has one pretty good artist signed and he is probably always looking for more talent. Whatever. I am sure most of the players were out partying too.
The media likes to blow things way out of proportion and act like Puritans when somebody does something stupid.
All it really means is his fellow players and coaches will NOT be voting him back anytime soon. But he can still play and it is not an easy TRADE to consider because you do not normally give up pro Bowl caliber left tackles in the NFL.
But as I said before, the Vikings have to give up something to get something!
Some interesting proposals
And seems like it would be advantageous to both sides.
Would prefer Loadholt rather than McKinne, in all honesty
"'Tis a bird I love, with its brooding note, And the trembling throb in its mottled throat; There's a human look in its swelling breast, And the gentle curve of its lowly crest; And I often stop with the fear I feel-- He runs so close to the rapid wheel." Nathaniel Parker Willis, "The Belfrey Pigeon"
How about
Osi and the Giants 2010 first for your 2010 first and 3rd picks?
by G Fan in England on Feb 5, 2010 5:34 AM EST reply actions

by 




















